10 April 2016

The Problematic Material Within Left Wing Rap

Rap, as a genre, is easy to criticise for its materialistic and problematic lyricism. The mainstream, big-name, artists seemingly focusing most of their efforts on promoting a materialistic existence, free from critical analysis of the conditions their race, culture, or social class are faced with on a day-to-day basis. Furthermore, much of the rap you encounter when you switch the radio station to BBC 1Xtra, Capital Xtra, or Kiss actively appears to be promoting the destructive and hedonistic lifestyle that is doing nothing more than maintaining the status quo.

Often these mainstream rappers afflict upon their audiences notions of abnormality in groups who are also marginalised in society. Where females and LGBT groups, who should be allies in the struggles facing the communities from which most of these rappers emerge, are marginalised by the attitudes towards them expressed in the lyrics.

There is, however, plenty of artists within the genre that critically analyse the conditions of the disaffected within society. Among my favourite artists are Lowkey, Blue Scholars, Looptroop Rockers, Lupe Fiasco, KRS-One, Logic, and countless others worthy of mention if I was interested in simply writing a list rather than a blog post. They are artists that devote their music to facing the real issues within society. Rarely, if ever, would you hear one of these artists name check a brand or boast about the amount of money they earn and how this allows them to exert power of females. 

As a Marxist these artists are a blessing. I can listen to a genre of music I enjoy with a core message which I can identify with. They are, whether they identify with it or not, undeniably aligned more towards the socialist end of the spectrum than free-market liberalists. 

There is a glaring issue with much of the music produced by artists within this rap sub-genre however. That is because many of the more famous artists promote conspiracy theories as a source of the problems facing their communities. 

Immortal Technique, as an example, is one of the more problematic rappers within the genre due to his frequent usage of divisive terminologies and a prime example of this conspiratorial scapegoating. As a rapper he does tackle problems blighting communities within the third world, such as Neo-Imperialism, but whilst doing so will make references to the Illuminati, Stonemasons, 9/11 as an inside job, and even the biblical rising of the seven headed dragon, a popular conspirituality which believes that the seven heads are represented by living people on earth (represented by your Bushes and Bin-Ladens in Techniques lyrics).

Whilst this could be dismissed as lyric craft, whereby a picture is painted for the audience to enhance the song, it is the frequency in which these references are made which causes the issue. Along with many other rappers of the sub-genre, too much time is devoted to encouraging the audience that there are powerful secret societies working behind the scenes to perpetuate the inequality blighting the communities they inhabit. These rappers, while maintaining a useful core message, are watering down the power of their words with nonsense about nefarious, hidden, groups.

Rather than being a force for social change it actually reinforces the position of the hegemonic class within society. Whilst the oppressed and disaffected are concentrating on non-existent forces as the root cause of societal problems they are not focusing on the people within society truly profiting from their oppression. The capitalist class. Rap can be a powerful tool of expression for the working class, for black and minority ethnic groups, for women, and if the genre got its act together and stopped marginalising the LGBT groups it can becoming a powerful tool for them too. It is a problem that blights too much of the conversation of people who otherwise would identify exclusively as left-wing in their political alignment. And, in rap, one song is capable influencing an audience far greater than my pokey little blog, or the countless others like mine, could manage in a lifetime of articles.

Rap is musical poetry. It encourages, or should do, critical expression and reflection. But too often the gun is pointed in the wrong direction. Towards things that do not matter, things that promote the capitalist ideal, towards potential allies, or things that do not exist. 

It can be a rallying point for communities. A way to share experiences with other people from similar or differing backgrounds. It can highlight and bring understanding of the conditions of life an oppressed group faces on a daily basis. But only if used correctly.

I'll leave this post with a song from Akala, who for me is the exemplar of this particular genre and what it could be once free from the distractions of conspiracy theories.


01 April 2016

Conspiracy Theory: Beliefs and Where They Emerge From

The growth in popularity of conspiracy theories has interested many social researchers and theorists for the last few decades. Commonly they are associated with the Kennedy Assassination or the threat of Communism in post-World War Two America today, with the widening availability of the internet, they are influencing more people than ever before. Only recently has the Conspiracy theory become part of the mainstream cultural landscape and political discourse, although often dismissed as being beliefs held by a small groups of outsiders. Conspiracy theories serve as explanations for difficult and complex systems that govern peoples lives. They hold great importance to people in an age where increasingly abstract forces control economics and globalisation threatens the traditional world view that previous generations would have held. To examine the conspiracy theory firstly, the models for understanding conspiratorial world-views require analysis. The work done by social researchers into the conspiracy theory has developed a few interesting understandings of what they are and how they develop in a society, which include firstly, 'Agency Panic' which briefly means that the loss of civil liberties for the general population is often a central theme to conspiracy theories. This may explain their appeal in a society in which liberal individualism is valued highly, with the fear of this loss of freedoms being central to a wide range of perceived conspiracies designed to subjugate a whole society or particular groups within a society. Secondly, the 'Paranoid Style' was a term originally developed by Hofstadter to explain the paranoid nature of American political discourse and is useful to understand the cultural and political landscape of the USA that targets all non-capitalist ideologies as the work of conspirators and secret societies. After this the phenomenon of 'Improvisational Millennialism' discussed by Barkun will be examined along with his types of conspiracies and his understanding of the Stigmatised knowledge favoured by conspiracy theorists. With this increased exposure to Conspiracy theories, the adoption of conspiracies into the apocalyptic milieu by Dispensationalists, the emergence of 'New Age' spiritualities and the rise in belief of extra-terrestrial life and UFOs, a new form of Conspiracy theory has emerged which has been called 'Conspiritualities', I will use Ward and Voas to explain where these beliefs have emanated from. I will take these models for understanding conspiracies and then apply them to the blog '2012 The Awakening'. This will create for a context to the conspiracy theory theories to be examined, thus providing an exploration of where and why the values and anxieties of the conspiracy theorist exist. 

The growing popularity of conspiracy theories according to Melley can be attributed to the “newly expanded definition, which accords the conspiracy broad explanatory power and enormous political utility” (Melley, 2000: 9). This definition accounts for its growing usage amongst the political elite and those who operate in the arena of ideological reproduction such as the media. The definition in its expanded form can be used to frame any opposing set of ideals or values to the accuser as being the work of conspirators. This panic response to opposing political ideologies can in some cases be a useful tool for the state to mobilise and generate support for its causes, therefore, heightening its popularity (Melley, 2000). However, a more common usage understands the state or at least part of the states apparatuses as being conspiratorial. This is how conspiracy theories play a particular role in society, they offer an explanation to a complex series of interlocking structures that govern our lives. For the average person, who does not possess all the required knowledge to make sense of the geopolitical and economic forces that govern the changes that they experience, they offer an understandable relation between causality and effect. The conspiracy theory therefore, offers a simplified explanation of the complex nature of the modern world (Melley, 2000). One way of understanding the rise in the popularity of conspiracy theories in society is 'Agency Panic', the idea that conspiracies are formed out of a “sense of diminished human agency, a feeling that individuals cannot effect meaningful social action” (Melley, 2000: 11). Melley defines agency panic as having two distinct but connected aspects, both expressing the fear of the loss of individuality amongst society and a diminished sense of personal agency,  with “a belief that the world is full of “programmed” or “brainwashed” subjects, addicts, automatons, or “mass-produced” persons” (Melley, 2000: 12). The second form of conspiracy is one which is associated with secret societies or hidden agendas within visible structures of government, religions, or big businesses. Conspiracy theories offer a solution to the groups of people who feel as though in the modern world that they inhabit they cannot exhibit their individuality and be truly autonomous, as social structures and organisations are inhibiting their ability to exercise these freedoms. This frames the individual and their actions in opposition to societal forces that fight between each other for control of human agency. By developing a conspiratorial world-view that insinuates that all social structures are inherently in opposition to the individual those that believe in the conspiracy can ignore differences in backgrounds and form a community of conspiracy theorists. This malleability of the conspiracy theory, alongside the liberal ideals of the west, offers an explanation of its appeal to varying groups who perceive a social inequality or their disengagement from society as being a consequence of conspiracies.

The 'Paranoid Style' is a term to explain the rise of paranoid or conspiratorial beliefs amongst the political elite and their supporters in American politics, particularly during the Cold War, and the conspiracy theories enduring popularity to explain world events post Soviet Union. Two main groups of people are attracted to conspiracy theories, according to Daniel Pipes, these are the Disaffected and the Suspicious. The disaffected are groups who “dislike the existing order and offer radical idea about changing it” (Pipes, 1997; 2). This category explains the appeal and prevalence of widespread belief in conspiracy theory amongst two distinct bodies of people, Pipes highlights, as an example, the black community and the far right in America. The spread of conspiracy theory beliefs has not only been limited to the politically disengaged within society, this is where Pipes analysis of conspiracy theory becomes strongest, as he highlights the impact it has in the rich and well educated communities in the USA. This group he labels the Suspicious. These beliefs tend to align with the beliefs of the far right disaffected, in that they focus on NWO or Masonic conspiracies typically containing a Luciferian religious underpinning. Notable examples are Republican Robertson, who believes forces are trying to replace the Christian, Liberal Capitalist, and Democratic USA with “an occult-inspired world socialist dictatorship” (Robertson cited in Pipes, 1997: 10) and a former presidential candidate for the Democrats, LaRouche, claiming that the English monarchy is at the centre of a global conspiracy involving “unrestrained Capitalism” and thus advocating “total war against Great Britain” (Pipes, 1997: 12). Both these examples support the understanding that the rise of conspiracy theory in the USA can be evidenced in the political rhetoric of the elites who frame ideological differences as being part of a vast conspiracy to undermine American values (Melley, 2000; Pipes, 1997). Pipes analysis details connections between seemingly opposing conspiracy theorists and explains the techniques used by theorists to legitimise their work with historical 'evidence', regardless of the time-scale, presenting their conspiracies as occurring through long-standing avenues such as the Knights Templar and the Bavarian Illuminati. Commonly such theories apply obscure information in favour of information that is generally accepted by the establishment and they tend to be protective of their sources stating that they wish to protect the informant. In addition to this they do not reject information that has been proven to be forged, such as the 'Protocols of the Elders of Zion', and rely on bombarding the cynic with large amounts of data, such as names and dates, to make their assertions seem more credible. When confronted with information that disproves their conclusions they assert that this is evidence of an attempt to cover up their account of the situation and in turn reinforces their belief in a particular conspiracy theory (Pipes, 1997). Furthermore, all conspiracies and their targets are indicative of a few common assumptions, the goal of the conspirators is always to gain control through hidden methods. Whichever group or organisations gains the most from this, in the theorists mind, is the conductor of the conspiracy. To them history is full of conspiracies with nothing happening without the conspirators input and that nothing is as it seems with conspiracies always hidden and impossible for the average person to see (Pipes, 1997; Barkun, 2003). Although Pipes analysis offers similarities between conspiracy theories which are commonly used by the theorist to provide legitimacy to their world view it, however, assumes that all history is orchestrated by timeless groups and not one off events which some conspiracy theorists believe are the result of a single conspiracy. Thus, it ignores differences between types of conspiracy and the methods used by the organisations or groups, Michael Barkun in 'A Culture of Conspiracy' develops this in his analysis.

There are many different groups implicated in malevolent actions by Conspiracy theorists, Some of these groups operate in public and are well recognised whilst others are abstract and hard to identify, with symbolism or historic connections being used by the theorists to point to their existence. Barkun outlines three types of conspiracies; Event Conspiracy, Systematic Conspiracy and the Superconspiracy. The event conspiracy is a single unconnected event that has been conducted by a group with a limited goal intended to be enacted through the orchestration of the objective, systematic conspiracies and superconspiracies differ from these in that they are much larger in their scope; however there is a distinct difference between both classifications. A systematic conspiracy is connected to an organisation that has ambitions usually to gain control over a country or even the world with a broad range of goals that they want to achieve and a range of mechanisms to achieve their goals, these are usually connected to Masonic or Jewish groups. Superconspiracies are even larger than the systematic conspiracies in their scope with organisations, usually understood to be conspiratorial in their goals, being used as arms sometimes against one another to achieve the end goal of the puppet-masters. At the top of these hierarchies they are very secretive and their existence is hidden from view, unlike most of the systematic and event conspiracies whose alleged conspirators are well known groups or organisations even if non-existent (Barkun, 2003). Barkun establishes types of knowledge used by the conspiracy theorist and the millennialist adoption of an end-time scenario, not only in traditional religious based narratives but also by the secular theorists. In addition to this he comments on the rise of ‘Improvisational Millennialism’ as being a source behind many of the newer conspiritualities, stating that these “odd conceptual structures are apt to contain elements from more than one religious tradition, together with ideas from the New Age, occultism, science, and radical politics” (Barkun, 2003: 19). This willingness to adopt beliefs from many radically differing traditions has been facilitated in part, according to Barkun, by the widespread nature of internet usage alongside the decline in traditional structures of power and information, for example, organised religion. As with Pipes (1997) Barkun states that this borrowing from traditions is typified by the information and beliefs of many conspiracy theorists, who use unorthodox sources and reject the traditional accounts for events in the world. Barkun calls their chosen sources for information 'Stigmatized Knowledge'. He identifies five types of knowledge used by the conspiracy theorist, Forgotten Knowledge that our ancestors once held, Superseded Knowledge which has been deemed false by science, Ignored Knowledge usually held by groups lacking in cultural capital, Rejected Knowledge which has always been considered false by the establishment, and Suppressed Knowledge hidden from us by those who control the power structures (Barkun, 2003). These ideas presented by Barkun have a great deal of commonality with conspiritualities in their assumptions and their chosen 'knowledge' as such it is hard to distinguish between conspirituality and improvised millennialism.

Conspiritualities are a blending of New Age beliefs from the cultic milieu and the conspiracy theory. Although neither have much in common with each other on the surface they have grown rapidly in popularity. This connection between the two worlds of spirituality and conspiracy may have been facilitated by the increased exposure to conspiracy theories through the media and the internet during the mid-late 90's and the need for large numbers of Americans to “experience spiritual growth” (Ward and Voas, 2011: 110). In creating their understanding of the world they borrow heavily from both the New Age and conspiracy narratives. A key theme of conspiritualities is the transformation of the world through an awakening of the population. They seek to enlighten the masses and in doing so expose the shadow forces manipulating the world (Ward and Voas, 2011). It is at this point that the two worlds of conspiracy and the New Age meet in, what Ward and Voas call, a “politico-spiritual philosophy” (Ward and Voas, 2011: 104). Where traditional conspiracy theories are predominantly right-wing in their politics the conspirituality employs traditions of the left. The awakening of the people leading to a new higher form of consciousness as the end of the 'old paradigm', particularly echoing the Marxist idea that the working class consciousness unifying would bring about the end of history and a new historical epoch. Interestingly the New Age cultic milieu offers a world that allows for hyper-individualisation, and as such, the spiritual shopper to pick and choose what aspects suit their life, thereby creating their own religiosity and world-view. This helps to resolve the autonomy anxiety expressed by the conspiracy theorist, alongside the inherent ability for a conspiracy theory to aid in recapturing some perceived sense of autonomy lost to the powerful forces controlling the world, giving the individual “purpose and focus” (Stewart and Harding, 1999: 294). Ward and Voas note that conspirituality is largely an “internet-based movement with a relatively modest presence in 'real life'” (Ward and Voas, 2011: 104). As such there is a need to examine one of the many conspirituality blogs on the internet.

The blog '2012 The Awakening' is edited by a person called Annette, who according to her About page, is a 'Starseed' who aims to “help others awaken to their Divine potential, to raise awareness about enormous metaphysical and geological earth changes unfolding at this time and to assist people in remembering why we have all chosen to experience this truly amazing time to be alive” (Annette, 2013). The blogs 'categories' include subjects such as 'The 2012 Effect – Strange new earth anomalies', 'Dark Cabal', 'ET's/Contactees', 'Guided Meditation', 'Starseeds' and 'Illuminati'. This mixture of spiritual and conspiratorial aspects largely collected from external sources are posted by Annette onto the site with links to the original source, generally from other conspiracy theorists or 'New Age' spiritualists, although links to newspaper articles are not uncommon. The blogs focus is on the 2012 prophecy and the associated transformation of human consciousness. 

Posted on December 18th 2012 “The Shift of the Ages” by Patricia Diane Cota-Robles is a prime example of the spiritual shopping that occurs amongst the conspirituality movement. The post states that a shift in the positioning of the Earth in relation to the Milky Way’s galactic core will cause a shift in consciousness amongst the entirety of humanity (Cota-Robles, 2012). This understanding of the 2012 prophecy has borrowed from the Mayan calendar, Christianity, Astrology, and elements from the cultic milieu, such as Light work and Vibrational frequencies having an effect on the planet and leading to the creation of a 'New Earth'. This shift is presented as an entering into the Age of Aquarius and signalling the return of Christ to humanity and the establishment of heaven on Earth. Therefore, it fits with Barkun's 'Improvised Millennialism' as a form of imminent spiritual awakening not wholly connected to a religious or secular understanding of an end of history scenario. A post made after the uneventful end of the Mayan calendar on the 22nd December 2012 offers the believer comfort that the ascension into a new form of earthly consciousness did take place, via a channelled message from non-physical entities, stating that “we know that you are well across the midpoint of your threshold NOW! We also see that there are many among you who feel disoriented, and aren’t quite sure where they are! They are not sure if they crossed, or if they even found a threshold to cross at all!” (Dagley, 2012) before offering solace that if the believer keeps moving forward they will begin to see that they have crossed the threshold. This reaction to an uneventful passing of a millennialist event is quite similar to the way that Millennialists can adapt their beliefs and world-views despite their predictions, for example of the rapture or Christ’s return on a particular date, being proved incorrect, It is commonly observed that they often continue to have faith in the biblical prophecy merely believing that they had misinterpreted the signs. A prominent example of this would be the Millerites who after their failed prophecy a large proportion of them split, adapted their understanding of the biblical end times and “formed their own denomination, Seventh-Day Adventists” (Fenster, 2008: 207).

Posted on the 4th December 2011, the article “Andromeda Council: East China Sea 6.9 quake – Undersea reptilian base destroyed” states that the earthquake that happened on the 8th November 2011 was the result of a “sonic energy beam strike” (Webre, 2011) from space by another alien race with the intention of destroying this Reptilian complex. It is in this posting that the picture of conspirituality becomes the clearest, it is from within the editors note the relationship between New Age beliefs and conspiracy theory is expressed. The editor writes that the “Reptilian bases were sending out beams of fear and negative energy” and that “if the unwashed masses knew the power to create a better life was within, game over the ruling elite could no longer maintain their control” (Annette, 2011). Comparisons between this understanding of collective consciousness being awoken between amongst the 'masses' leading to a Utopian future echoes the Marxist understanding, that the dawning of true collective consciousness amongst the working class would lead to revolution to overthrow the capitalist elite. This can be understood within the context of this blog as being “a paranoiac desire” which is “a “normal” desire within the highly structured economic and cultural regime of capitalism” to view those behind the power structures of Capitalism as sinister (Fenster, 2008: 108). This is further supported by the blogs categories, for example 'Capitalism Run Amuck', that indicates a broadly socialist ideological perspective being held by the editor and the call for humanity to “stop focusing on money and materialism so that we can better serve each other” (Annette, 2011). The UFO conspiracy, and all of its assorted assumptions about state secrets and human history, can be seen as an ambiguous commentary on our own existence within an increasingly secular and confusing world. Stewart and Harding describe it as “a postmodern popular midrash on contemporary American politics, society, culture, and everyday life” (Stewart and Harding, 1999: 296).

More traditional aspects of conspiracy theory are also covered within the blog such as the 'Illuminati', in a post from June 29th 2013, written about a large scale of this conspiracy involving 'black operations' and secret societies. This indicates a belief that a Superconspiracy is the guiding force behind human history. The opening paragraph states that the post is a “comprehensive and well researched account of America's hidden history” and that “the history taught in schools and university's was written and shaped by the winners over many generations, until recently very few people knew the truth or had the whole picture” (Annette, 2013). The opening paragraph of this post highlights both the belief in suppressed knowledge from within the conspiracy theorist literature as the right source of information and all other sources being misinformation from the many different groups of conspirators. As noted by Barkun, a conspiracy theory that encompasses many different groups makes it incredibly resistant to contradictory information “for if everyone besides the conspiracist and the reader is complicit, then no information outside conspiracist literature can be relied upon” (Barkun, 2003: 69). The article referenced on the blog places the conspiracies earliest years in the 17th Century with the formation of the 'East India Company' by Queen Elizabeth I. The author writes that “history has not been a random series of events, but rather a carefully planned and executed 'design' of land, wealth and resource grabbing by a small number of wealthy and privileged individuals bent on world domination” (Not known, 2013). The purpose of the 'East India Company' was to secretly learn how to manipulate the financial landscape of India whilst selling Opium into the Chinese, by doing this the author claims the 'East India Company' became hugely wealthy and merged with the British monarchy to become the 'Committee of 300', which is subsequently placed at the top of the Superconspiracies hierarchy by the author (Not Known, 2013). This historical context for the conspiracy and the implications it has upon the world is noted by Hofstadter who writes that the 'paranoid style' is more complex than a simple belief in a conspiracy theory and that those who think in this manner do not see “conspiracies or plots here and there in history, but that they regard a ‘vast’ or ‘gigantic’ conspiracy as the motive force in historical events” (Hofstadter cited in Bratich, 2008: 32). The attacks on and placing of corporate and ideological structures within the context of a conspiracy theory by the author of the article is indicative of what Frederic Jameson calls a “poor person's cognitive mapping” (Jameson cited in Fenster, 2008: 108). By this he means it allows for the complexities of Capitalist influences on the individuals life to be understood in way that makes sense to the person who would not otherwise be able to grasp the intricate nature of forces that determine the course of history.

Although the conspiracy theory has been the subject of much political discourse in America in particular throughout the 20th Century, with politicians embracing ideas of non-conformity to their political ideologies as being part of a world-wide conspiracy to subjugate and control the American population. Often organisations ideas like the UN, or more commonly Communism, took on the role of malevolent organisations seeking to impose anti-individualistic ideals upon the world. This world-view is most prominent amongst the Far-right and Christian elements of American politics, with themes of the apocalypse often appearing within the conspiratorial rhetoric. The political paranoia and subsequent conspiracy rhetoric has gained momentum in recent years, this is due to the availability of conspiracy theories through the internet and, increasingly, the conventional media. A distrust of the official accounts of events such as 9/11 can lead individuals to a plethora of internet sites offering alternative explanations for the events that unfolded from a non-corporate source. This information could be particularly appealing to groups who feel alienated from the masses within society. This is why the belief in conspiracies has spread to those on the left, increasingly becoming an commonplace part of the collective world-view amongst Socialists. The alternative access to information the internet provides enables users to build a large community of conspiracy theorists. It also provides the chance to pick and choose what they wish to believe in accordance with what suits their individual outlook on life and society. Its distinction from the traditional sources of information allows the conspiracy theorists to exercise their own autonomy and feel as though they are making a difference in the world, in so far that they are revealing the truth behind a perceived loss of agency in the world. The rise of internet based conspiracy communities has facilitated the spread of alternative spiritualities and millennialist ideas about the end of history or shifting paradigms, this is more commonly being incorporated into the conspiracy theorists understanding of the world. Furthermore, the merging of spirituality and conspiracy theory into conspiritualities is the result of the changing nature of society and the increased levels of people looking for answers away from the traditional sources whether they are political or spiritual in nature. They are increasingly choosing the internet to discover alternative understandings of spirituality and world events. This adaptable approach to their belief systems sees the individual borrowing ideas from multiple religions and cultures in constructing their understanding of prophecies and world events such as the Mayan calendar, which was to destroy the world or bring about a paradigm shift depending on the theory, and gained world wide coverage. This event largely entered into the public consciousness due to the multiplicity of internet sites, films, books and articles written about the many different possibilities offered by the conspiritualitists. Ufology whilst always popular amongst the western imagination has become a prime example of the conspiritual understanding of the universe and the world, with many differing explanations of the nature of the aliens, from benevolent extra-dimensional non-physical beings to malevolent terrestrial underground shape-shifters controlling humanity. The conspiritual milieu allows for the theorists to create their own understanding of the hidden forces amongst humanity. These alien beliefs can, and usually do, take the form of Superconspiracies. It is within superconspiracies that large proportions of the internet-based conspiracy theorists beliefs reside, such as secret societies manipulating the world in accordance with the views of the NWO, Jews, Illuminati or Aliens. Access to this stigmatised knowledge through the internet has allowed for conspiracy theorists to create incredibly complex and hard to discredit versions of world power-structures with secret societies controlling every aspect of human history. This has only further aided the growing popularity of conspiracy theories due to an increased dissatisfaction with events in the world caused by secret societies with goals counter to humanities best interests.


References

Melley, T. (2000). Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in Postwar America. New York: Cornell University Press

Pipes, D. (1997). Conspiracy. New York: The Free Press.

Barkun, M. (2003). A Culture of Conspiracy: Apocalyptic Visions in Contemporary America. London: University of California Press.

Ward, C and Voas, D. (2011). The Emergence of Conspirituality. Journal of Contemporary Religion. 26 (1), 103-121.

Annette. (Unknown). About. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/about/. Last accessed 29/11/2013.

Fenster, M. (2008). Conspiracy Theories: Secrecy and Power in American Culture. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Bratich, J. Z. (2008). Conspiracy Panics: Political Rationality and Popular Culture. Albany: State University of New York Press.

Cota-Robles, P. D. (2012). ♥ ♥ ♥ The Shift of the Ages ♥ ♥ ♥. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/2012/12/18/%E2%99%A5-%E2%99%A5-%E2%99%A5-the-shift-of-the-ages-%E2%99%A5-%E2%99%A5-%E2%99%A5/. Last accessed 30/11/2013.

Dagley, J. (2012). 12.22.12 Yes,You ARE Crossing! Keep Going, Beloved!. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/2012/12/22/12-22-12-yesyou-are-crossing-keep-going-beloved/. Last accessed 30/11/2013.

Annette. (2011). Andromeda Council: East China Sea 6.9 quake – Undersea reptilian base destroyed. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/2011/12/04/andromeda-council-east-china-sea-6-9-quake-undersea-reptilian-base-destroyed-add-a-comment-alfred-lambremont-webres-photo-alfred-lambremont-webre-seattle-exopolitics-examiner-continu/. Last accessed 01/12/2013.

Webre, A. L. (2011). Andromeda Council: East China Sea 6.9 quake – Undersea reptilian base destroyed. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/2011/12/04/andromeda-council-east-china-sea-6-9-quake-undersea-reptilian-base-destroyed-add-a-comment-alfred-lambremont-webres-photo-alfred-lambremont-webre-seattle-exopolitics-examiner-continu/. Last accessed 01/12/2013.

Not Known. (2013). Secret Societies: The Committee of 300, The Jesuits, 13 Illuminati Papal Bloodline Families, The Corporation of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, The Federal Reserve Bank, Operation Paperclip & MK-Ultra…MUST READ. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/2013/06/29/secret-societies-the-committee-of-300-the-jesuits-13-illuminati-papal-bloodline-families-the-corporation-of-the-united-states-of-america-the-federal-reserve-bank-operation-paperclip-mk-ul/. Last accessed 01/12/2013.

Annette. (2013). Secret Societies: The Committee of 300, The Jesuits, 13 Illuminati Papal Bloodline Families, The Corporation of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, The Federal Reserve Bank, Operation Paperclip & MK-Ultra…MUST READ. Available: http://ascendingstarseed.wordpress.com/2013/06/29/secret-societies-the-committee-of-300-the-jesuits-13-illuminati-papal-bloodline-families-the-corporation-of-the-united-states-of-america-the-federal-reserve-bank-operation-paperclip-mk-ul/. Last accessed 01/12/2013.


Stewart, K and Harding, S. (1999). BAD ENDINGS: American Apocalypsis. Annual Review of Anthropology. 28 (1), 285-310.